potatoes and baby formula
One concerned the introduction of a new breed of potato in the mountains of Peru. The potato, as everyone knows, originated in Peru. In markets in Peru you can find literally hundreds of varieties of potatoes. But those native Peruvian potatoes do not look much like the potatoes most Americans are familiar with. They are a lot smaller. So some well-intentioned scientists and activists with the World Bank and UN Food Program came into Peru and introduced a new strain of potato that had been developed for them. This new potato was bigger. It had a higher starch content. Therefore, it would feed more poor Peruvians and help stamp out hunger.
The seeds for this new potato was called "improved seeds".
But my professor argues that there are many different ways to define "improved" and while these potatoes may have been improved in starch content, there are several other factors in which quite the opposite was true.
The native Peruvian potatotes had been growing in the Andes for a long time. They were well adapted there. But the new potatoes were vulnerable to certain pests and diseases which the local potatoes had long overcome through adaptation and natural selection. So the Peruvians had to start using fertilizers and pesticides to keep these new potatoes healthy. This cost money. The pesticides had to be imported from Western nations, and paid for in foreign exchange. They also had negative environmental impacts.
My professor also explains how the new potatoes had negative impacts upon the cultural scene. Traditionally, Peruvian women were the farmers of the society. They knew many things about cultivating potatoes. This is called "indigenous technical knowledge". But the new potatoes were advocated by outsides - by Western scientists and economists, and by Peruvian technocrats, government agents, and scientists trained in Western-style universities in Lima. As a result, these women lost their role in society. They were replaced, marginalized, cast aside.
The other example he gave concerns baby formula and is particularly insiduous. I think it's pretty much common knowledge that human breast milk is the best thing for babies. But baby formula manufacturers would like to have people believe otherwise. They want to replace an essential source of nourishment - one which is natural and free - with a manufactured substitute that is supposedly more "convenient". (the hidden, more culturally-charged subtext is that "modern", "civilized", "respectable" women do not breast feed in public because it is "obscene"). My professor describes how Nestle went to India and Sri Lanka in the 90s to open up new markets for their baby formula. They sent agents into maternity wards at hospitals DRESSES AS NURSES and handed out a week's supply of their baby formula free to all new mothers, along with the advice that it was the modern, healthier thing to do. Now, if you go for one week without breastfeeding after giving birth, your breasts dry up and you are no longer able to produce milk. So as soon as the free samples ran out, these mothers were forced to go out and buy expensive baby formula. Now, baby formula may not be as good as real breast milk, but the scientists at Nestle have at least come close. Their product is by no means BAD for the baby. In northern, temperate climates, that is. But this was India and Sri Lanka, where climates are hot and tropical. Where electricity is sporadic or, in many parts, non-existent. And therefore, where refridgeration, or sterilization of baby bottles, is not an option. Baby formula must be refridgerated. And baby bottles must be sterilized. Without those conditions, this baby formula was incredibly unsafe and ended up causing bushels of babies to become incredibly sick, and their mothers could no longer produce human breast milk for them.
The defenders of the formula say it is necessary since 2% of all women are unable to produce milk. But traditional societies already have mechanisms in place to deal with such risks. They have wet-nurses, and in any given village, there will always be some woman who is willing to nurse another woman's baby should she not be able.
